(Okay, this post turned out significantly longer than I intended, sorry about that. If you don't want to read the whole thing, at least read the part in bold, that's what I mainly wanted to share.)
I read an interesting article in Time magazine this morning while I was waiting at the Dr. office. It's about a book entitled Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother by Amy Chua. You can read the full article here. She's Chinese and feels that the Chinese way of mothering is superior to the American way because the Chinese are much more successful than we are. So she's very strict with her children and demands a lot from them, such as requiring them to play the piano for 7 hours straight until they get the song right. Or rejecting her young daughters birthday card "because she didn't spend enough time on it." Or not allowing her children to have friends.
When I first started reading I was thinking, "Wow, this lady is NUTS! What an awful mother!" I was so appalled, but in some cases I think that she's got an idea worth considering. But overall, I felt that she's taken it all to the serious extreme. Her justification for how she parents is that she's preparing her children to be successful adults. And she's right, she is preparing her children to succeed in the business part of life. But there's much more to being an adult than being the best at everything.
What is our responsibility to our children? We want them to be successful adults, but we also have a knowledge that Amy Chua may not, we know that we are children of God and that our main and most important goal is to return to live with Him again. So, how does Amy Chua's type of parenting fit into that knowledge? Should we be focusing more on our children's academia, or is it okay to let them be kids and play with their friends? Am I failing my children and our country by not subscribing to this woman's ideas? I'm sure a happy medium is the correct answer.
The article quoted one study that I found very interesting.
"[Standford psychologist Carol] Dweck has conducted studies with hundreds of students, mostly early adolescents, in which experimenters gave the subjects a set of difficult problems from an IQ test. Afterward, some of the young people were praised for their ability: "You must be smart at this." Others were praised for their effort: "You must have worked really hard." The kids who were complimented on their intelligence were much more likely to turn down the opportunity to do a challenging new task that they could learn from. "They didn't want to do anything that would expose their deficiencies and call into question their talent," Dweck says. Ninety percent of the kids who were praised for their hard work, however, were eager to take on the demanding new exercise."
I find that so interesting. So I tried it with my kids this morning. They were helping me carry in the groceries and instead of thanking them for being so helpful, like I normally do, I said, "Wow, you're being hard workers! Good job for working so hard!" They beamed at that! They were so proud of themselves.
I don't agree with most of what this lady did to her children, but I'm glad I read the article because of the study about praising your children for hard work. It's such an obvious thing, but I wouldn't have thought of it.
"Finish each day and be done with it. You have done what you could. Some blunders and absurdities have crept in; forget them as soon as you can. Tomorrow is a new day. You shall begin it serenely and with too high a spirit to be encumbered with your old nonsense."-Emerson
Thursday, January 27, 2011
Wednesday, January 26, 2011
Haircuts
Sunday, January 23, 2011
A Tooth Story
Debbie has a couple more loose teeth and we've been telling her to wiggle them whenever we remember. Today at the beginning of Sacrament Meeting, Chad noticed her tooth and told her to wiggle it. So she wiggled it and to our surprise it fell out onto her lap. So then she yelled, "DADDY, I LOST MY TOOTH!!" Mind you, Sacrament Meeting had already started, it was pretty quiet. I grabbed the tooth and noticed she had gotten some blood on her brand new dress and saw that she was bleeding a little bit so I went to hand the tooth to Chad except that then I DROPPED IT! So here's Debbie jumping up and down laughing, while I'm trying to get her to keep her mouth closed so she didn't get more blood on her dress and the rest of us were scrambling trying to find a lost little tooth! We found it later under the pew. But it was pretty funny. So Debbie's lost tooth, turned into and actual lost tooth.
Saturday, January 22, 2011
Just A Sip
I heard Cosette getting into the fridge today so I went to go help her with whatever she might need and this is what I found...
She was completely unperturbed, like she had every right to be drinking straight from the milk jug.
For those who know Cosette, this really isn't surprising. She's just a self-sufficient kind of girl.
hahaha! Oh man, she cracks me up.
Sunday, January 16, 2011
The Book of Mormon
[And yes, she's sucking her thumb again. That's thanks to me and the stress I caused in December. These little ones are resilient, but they can certainly feel stress and anxiety from their parents.]
Saturday, January 15, 2011
Debbie Lynn
This little girl is amazing. Everyone should be blessed with a daughter as wonderful as Debbie. She's thoughtful, helpful, giving, optimistic, and happy. Today she learned how to sweep the kitchen. She was so excited when Chad told her she was going to learn how to sweep. She's so funny, she LOVES to help! A few weeks ago I told her I needed her to clean off the table and she got excited and asked, "Like a chore?" I said yes and she said, "Yay!! I love chores!" And she does! [At least for now anyway ☺]
She's so thoughtful too. She's had a bit of a grumble in her throat and had to keep clearing her throat. Well, yesterday it was getting annoying and I told her as much. So that sweet little girl kept getting up from watching her show to leave the room to clear her throat so she didn't annoy me. HOW SWEET IS THAT!?!?
And she's so helpful with the younger kids too, she helps them out and loves to be the big sister. We're just so thankful that we've been blessed with her.
Friday, January 7, 2011
Cute
~
I've realized that I have to change the way I word things when I want the kids to be good. We'd be going into the store and I'd tell the kids, "You can have a treat after if you're good." And they'd invariable respond, "I'm good mommy! I'm good!" I didn't want them doubting that they were good people so I changed it to 'behave.' Then I got this, "I'm 'have mommy! I've been 'have!" So I've finally decided on "Listen and obey." "You can have a treat if you listen and obey." They're responding better to that. :)
~
Debbie is so funny, she was asking us yesterday if we could buy a sled and we said maybe next year and she squealed, "YES! We might get a sled and we might not!!"
~
Isaac LOVES to watch Chad play the wii. Chad plays Lego Batman and now just recently got the How to Train Your Dragon game. Isaac begs him every night when he gets home to play the wii so he can watch. Well, the other day was a particularly difficult day for Isaac, throwing tantrums and such, and so when Chad got home and he asked him to play I said no because Isaac had been such a pill. Well, Isaac didn't like that, so Chad talked to him and told him that he has to listen to me and stop throwing tantrums or daddy isn't going to be able to play games for him. Something worked, because Isaac has been amazing ever since! And it's funny because Chad got home from school the other night and looked at me and said, "Isaac has been a good boy today...?" I gave him permission to play nintendo. haha!
Monday, January 3, 2011
Isaac
Cousins
The kids had a chance to go spend some time with their cousins last week and they loved it. My brother and sister-in-law took the kids for a few days and they had a blast. The kids always seem to have learned something new (good new) when they come home from their house. Just this morning Debbie said, "Mom's not our slave, she's our mom." Love it! I don't know if she picked it up there or not, but she didn't pick it up from us because we don't generally say that. The kids just love their cousins and I'm so grateful for siblings (and their spouses) who are so giving and loving and willing to let my kids come to their house for a few days.I have the best family in the world!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)